Please Vote The Best 3 Of These Edits

[ScottL]

Hey all... Little stuck here. I liked this shot in many different versions. But I wanted to get some opinions which are throw aways and which should be keepers..

Please Vote 3 out of the 11.

Comments also appreciated and encouraged.

http://www.photozo.com/album/showgallery.php?cat=4402

[Nomar]

Number 11 which you omitted from your poll.


But I would like to say sir step away from the Virtual Photographer and walk back slowly.

[ScottL]

What No Good??? lol

Damn I can't go back and edit it in!

I was not sure what I wanted to do with the shot... So I played a bit. The color was not right in the origina But I really liked the Compo. Than as I started playing I did not know where to go with it.

[Nomar]

Well just make a mental note about my vote then...

I know what you mean I try to stay away from virtual photographer for that reason. It gives you too many choices that then take up too much space on your HD.

[Antillano]

I went with 4, 6 and 9. Not easy descicion, but I find those to be the best in their category. I don’t think my vote was of much help since I didn’t choose between Sephia, B&W or Color. But the composition is very good so you can pretty much do anything with it.

[MrsHey]

I agree...great shot...I think I picked 6, 9, 10...it was tough, though! Me thinks you're having WAY fun with your new camera!!! Hehehe!

[trtjazz]

Scott pretty good shots from a unique perspective.

[happycamper]

Well, I like 4,5 and 9 best! The colors and the effects I think are what made me decide on those 3.

[jdog]

my votes are secret!!!!! no, I just really don't remember which ones I voted for 100%....I think it was 1, 10 and ?????

I am still hyperventelating over your Hulk shot today....then it disappeared.......VERY NICE! You will do nicely in a speedo.....

Congrats on the shots

Tracy

[ScottL]

Thanks everyone... Took about 300+ shots in Time Square tonight... And my travels to... This was surely a test... It was rough. So much going one at once.

[HarleyCowgirl]

Alright,my votes are in.
#1 - Love the subtle colors,very pretty.
#6 - The colors are fantastic,great lighting and can't quite put my finger on the word I'm looking for but it just gives off a cool essence I think.
#9 - Really like the soft B&W with this shot,just works IMHO.

One thing though I was sorta surprised to see no one had mentioned possible cloning(?) marks in the top left hand sky?Or is that funky clouds?Not sure,maybe it's my monitor but I thought I'd mention it anyhow.
Great shot though Scott,you've definately got the shots. ;-)
Trayci

[ScottL]

Thanks Trayci... I must go back and look...

[eric1]

i think #1 was the best edit. more detail was preserved after prossesing. very nice comp. the B/W's were a little bland. it's hard to get a deep rich B/W. i like to use the monochrome setting in the channel mixer in PSCS. it leaves some of the red channel. good job Scott.

[ScottL]

Thanks Eric... One learns something new everyday...

I like to hear how others convert. It definately helps. As I have taken a real liking to B&W